Juniper Networks this week disclosed an ambitious plan to unite the industry around a common vision for public networking that attempts to resolve some shortcomings the vendor says are inherent in the Internet.

Juniper's Infranet Initiative seeks to develop two interfaces -- a user-to-network interface between customers and service providers, and a so-called inter-carrier interface between service providers -- that adhere to a set of interconnection standards that establish a "lowest common denominator" required for implementation. Today, equipment vendors and service providers can build from an array of standard and non-standard interconnection schemes that, when implemented differently, disrupt interoperability and service consistency.

When interconnecting via these two new interfaces, customers and service providers will construct an "infranet" that combines the ubiquitous connectivity of the Internet with the predictable performance and security of a private network, Juniper claims. This infranet will then ultimately provide the global infrastructure required to support machine-to-machine grid computing, unlock the full potential of Web-enabled applications and finally usher in the era of the online economy, the company boasts.

Juniper's table pounding is not unique. Scores of vendor-initiated "calls to action" have come and gone over the past 20 years, all under the guise of altruism. Most, however, turned out to be vendor-motivated, and produced little more than enough press releases to wallpaper the Pentagon and embarrassing admissions that the efforts petered out.

But some analysts think Juniper might have something here. Though only beleaguered business partner Lucent is on board now, they believe Juniper partners Siemens and Ericsson might climb on board.

"I think it has teeth, but I think the teeth that it has initially are as much political as technical," says Tom Nolle, president of consultancy CIMI in Voorhees, N.J. "We have to take a look at the question of whether the current standardization process launched and controlled by the IETF is completely responsive to the needs of non-Internet IP applications. Then we have to say, 'Is the technology of the products compatible with these applications?'"